Case Law Update Conor Dirks Case Law Update Conor Dirks

Appeals Court Rules No Private Right of Action for False Statements By Government

A former federal employee terminated by the United States Agency for International Development (“USAID”) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (“NOAA”) appealed his termination from both agencies under Title VII and also contended that NOAA violated a criminal statute that prohibits making false statements when the Agency allegedly lied about why he was terminated.

Read More
Case Law Update Conor Dirks Case Law Update Conor Dirks

Federal Circuit Reverses MSPB Order to Repay OPM Overpayment

After the Merit Systems Protection Board found that a retired federal employee failed to prove that the recovery of overpaid benefits from the Federal Employee Retirement System (“FERS”) would be against equity and good conscience, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed the MSPB’s decision, finding that the Administrative Judge’s analysis (which the full Board accepted) was not supported by substantial evidence, was erroneous, and that recovery of the overpayment was unconscionable given the “inexplicable” three-year delay by OPM to finalize the retiree’s benefits, and the additional four-year delay between the retiree’s request for reconsideration and OPM’s decision.

Read More
Case Law Update Conor Dirks Case Law Update Conor Dirks

Supreme Court: Veteran Can’t Be Forced To Indemnify Ex-Spouse When Electing Benefits

A retired Air Force Veteran’s divorce decree awarded his ex-wife 50 percent of the veteran’s future Air Force retirement pay, but thirteen years after the divorce, the veteran was found partially disabled due to an earlier service-related injury, and elected to give up an equal amount ($250 monthly) of retirement pay in order to receive disability pay – thereby reducing the value of his ex-wife’s 50 percent share by 50 percent of $250.

Read More
Case Law Update Michael J. Sgarlat Case Law Update Michael J. Sgarlat

Dismissal Due to the Suppression of Evidence Does Not Satisfy the Favorable Termination Element of a Malicious Prosecution Claim

In January 2010, police arrested Terry Margheim at his home in Greeley, CO on suspicion of domestic violence committed against his girlfriend. Weld County prosecutors then initiated a criminal prosecution against him. Margheim posted a $3,000 bond and was required to comply with a protection order to avoid contact with his girlfriend.

Read More
Case Law Update James P. Garay Heelan Case Law Update James P. Garay Heelan

Supreme Court to Decide Appellate Jurisdiction in Federal Employee “Mixed Case” Appeals

In the first case argued before Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch, Justices appeared to disagree about how to handle “mixed cases,” alleging both adverse employment actions against federal civil service employees and prohibited discrimination, where the Merit Systems Protection Board concludes it lacks jurisdiction because the employee was not subject to an appealable action.

Read More